Merge remote-tracking branch 'upstream/pull/2441'

app/models/relation.rb

@@ -121,31 +121,6 @@ class Relation < ActiveRecord::Base
     relation
   end
 
-  def to_xml
-    doc = OSM::API.new.get_xml_doc
-    doc.root << to_xml_node
-    doc
-  end
-
-  def to_xml_node(changeset_cache = {}, user_display_name_cache = {})
-    el = XML::Node.new "relation"
-    el["id"] = id.to_s
-
-    add_metadata_to_xml_node(el, self, changeset_cache, user_display_name_cache)
-
-    relation_members.each do |member|
-      member_el = XML::Node.new "member"
-      member_el["type"] = member.member_type.downcase
-      member_el["ref"] = member.member_id.to_s
-      member_el["role"] = member.member_role
-      el << member_el
-    end
-
-    add_tags_to_xml_node(el, relation_tags)
-
-    el
-  end
-
   # FIXME: is this really needed?
   def members
     @members ||= relation_members.map do |member|

app/models/way.rb

@@ -106,44 +106,6 @@ class Way < ActiveRecord::Base
     way
   end
 
-  # Find a way given it's ID, and in a single SQL call also grab its nodes and tags
-  def to_xml
-    doc = OSM::API.new.get_xml_doc
-    doc.root << to_xml_node
-    doc
-  end
-
-  def to_xml_node(visible_nodes = nil, changeset_cache = {}, user_display_name_cache = {})
-    el = XML::Node.new "way"
-    el["id"] = id.to_s
-
-    add_metadata_to_xml_node(el, self, changeset_cache, user_display_name_cache)
-
-    # make sure nodes are output in sequence_id order
-    ordered_nodes = []
-    way_nodes.each do |nd|
-      if visible_nodes
-        # if there is a list of visible nodes then use that to weed out deleted nodes
-        ordered_nodes[nd.sequence_id] = nd.node_id.to_s if visible_nodes[nd.node_id]
-      else
-        # otherwise, manually go to the db to check things
-        ordered_nodes[nd.sequence_id] = nd.node_id.to_s if nd.node&.visible?
-      end
-    end
-
-    ordered_nodes.each do |nd_id|
-      next unless nd_id && nd_id != "0"
-
-      node_el = XML::Node.new "nd"
-      node_el["ref"] = nd_id
-      el << node_el
-    end
-
-    add_tags_to_xml_node(el, way_tags)
-
-    el
-  end
-
   def nds
     @nds ||= way_nodes.collect(&:node_id)
   end

test/controllers/api/changesets_controller_test.rb

@@ -458,9 +458,9 @@ CHANGESET
       diff.root = XML::Node.new "osmChange"
       delete = XML::Node.new "delete"
       diff.root << delete
-      delete << super_relation.to_xml_node
+      delete << xml_node_for_relation(super_relation)
-      delete << used_relation.to_xml_node
+      delete << xml_node_for_relation(used_relation)
-      delete << used_way.to_xml_node
+      delete << xml_node_for_way(used_way)
       delete << xml_node_for_node(used_node)
 
       # update the changeset to one that this user owns
@@ -590,8 +590,8 @@ CHANGESET
       diff.root = XML::Node.new "osmChange"
       delete = XML::Node.new "delete"
       diff.root << delete
-      delete << other_relation.to_xml_node
+      delete << xml_node_for_relation(other_relation)
-      delete << used_way.to_xml_node
+      delete << xml_node_for_way(used_way)
       delete << xml_node_for_node(used_node)
 
       # update the changeset to one that this user owns
@@ -633,8 +633,8 @@ CHANGESET
       delete = XML::Node.new "delete"
       diff.root << delete
       delete["if-unused"] = ""
-      delete << used_relation.to_xml_node
+      delete << xml_node_for_relation(used_relation)
-      delete << used_way.to_xml_node
+      delete << xml_node_for_way(used_way)
       delete << xml_node_for_node(used_node)
 
       # update the changeset to one that this user owns
@@ -1175,7 +1175,7 @@ CHANGESET
       diff = XML::Document.new
       diff.root = XML::Node.new "osmChange"
       modify = XML::Node.new "modify"
-      xml_old_way = old_way.to_xml_node
+      xml_old_way = xml_node_for_way(old_way)
       nd_ref = XML::Node.new "nd"
       nd_ref["ref"] = create(:node, :lat => 3, :lon => 3).id.to_s
       xml_old_way << nd_ref
@@ -1487,7 +1487,7 @@ CHANGESET
 
       # add (delete) a way to it, which contains a point at (3,3)
       with_controller(WaysController.new) do
-        xml = update_changeset(way.to_xml, changeset_id)
+        xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(way), changeset_id)
         put :delete, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
         assert_response :success, "Couldn't delete a way."
       end

test/controllers/api/relations_controller_test.rb

@@ -525,28 +525,28 @@ module Api
       assert_response :forbidden
 
       # try to delete with an invalid (closed) changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(relation.to_xml,
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(relation),
                              private_user_closed_changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden
 
       # try to delete with an invalid (non-existent) changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(relation.to_xml, 0)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(relation), 0)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden
 
       # this won't work because the relation is in-use by another relation
-      xml = used_relation.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_relation(used_relation)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => used_relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden
 
       # this should work when we provide the appropriate payload...
-      xml = relation.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_relation(relation)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden
 
       # this won't work since the relation is already deleted
-      xml = deleted_relation.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_relation(deleted_relation)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => deleted_relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden
 
@@ -568,36 +568,36 @@ module Api
       assert_match(/Changeset id is missing/, @response.body)
 
       # try to delete with an invalid (closed) changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(relation.to_xml,
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(relation),
                              closed_changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict
 
       # try to delete with an invalid (non-existent) changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(relation.to_xml, 0)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(relation), 0)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict
 
       # this won't work because the relation is in a changeset owned by someone else
-      xml = update_changeset(relation.to_xml, create(:changeset).id)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(relation), create(:changeset).id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict,
                       "shouldn't be able to delete a relation in a changeset owned by someone else (#{@response.body})"
 
       # this won't work because the relation in the payload is different to that passed
-      xml = update_changeset(relation.to_xml, changeset.id)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(relation), changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => create(:relation).id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :bad_request, "shouldn't be able to delete a relation when payload is different to the url"
 
       # this won't work because the relation is in-use by another relation
-      xml = update_changeset(used_relation.to_xml, changeset.id)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(used_relation), changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => used_relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :precondition_failed,
                       "shouldn't be able to delete a relation used in a relation (#{@response.body})"
       assert_equal "Precondition failed: The relation #{used_relation.id} is used in relation #{super_relation.id}.", @response.body
 
       # this should work when we provide the appropriate payload...
-      xml = update_changeset(multi_tag_relation.to_xml, changeset.id)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(multi_tag_relation), changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => multi_tag_relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :success
 
@@ -607,18 +607,18 @@ module Api
              "delete request should return a new version number for relation"
 
       # this won't work since the relation is already deleted
-      xml = update_changeset(deleted_relation.to_xml, changeset.id)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(deleted_relation), changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => deleted_relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :gone
 
       # Public visible relation needs to be deleted
-      xml = update_changeset(super_relation.to_xml, changeset.id)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(super_relation), changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => super_relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :success
 
       # this works now because the relation which was using this one
       # has been deleted.
-      xml = update_changeset(used_relation.to_xml, changeset.id)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_relation(used_relation), changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => used_relation.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :success,
                       "should be able to delete a relation used in an old relation (#{@response.body})"
@@ -643,7 +643,7 @@ module Api
       # indirectly via the way), so the bbox should be [3,3,5,5].
       check_changeset_modify(BoundingBox.new(3, 3, 5, 5)) do |changeset_id|
         # add a tag to an existing relation
-        relation_xml = relation.to_xml
+        relation_xml = xml_for_relation(relation)
         relation_element = relation_xml.find("//osm/relation").first
         new_tag = XML::Node.new("tag")
         new_tag["k"] = "some_new_tag"
@@ -675,7 +675,7 @@ module Api
       [node1, node2, way1, way2].each do |element|
         bbox = element.bbox.to_unscaled
         check_changeset_modify(bbox) do |changeset_id|
-          relation_xml = Relation.find(relation.id).to_xml
+          relation_xml = xml_for_relation(Relation.find(relation.id))
           relation_element = relation_xml.find("//osm/relation").first
           new_member = XML::Node.new("member")
           new_member["ref"] = element.id.to_s
@@ -710,7 +710,7 @@ module Api
 
       check_changeset_modify(BoundingBox.new(5, 5, 5, 5)) do |changeset_id|
         # remove node 5 (5,5) from an existing relation
-        relation_xml = relation.to_xml
+        relation_xml = xml_for_relation(relation)
         relation_xml
           .find("//osm/relation/member[@type='node'][@ref='#{node2.id}']")
           .first.remove!
@@ -879,7 +879,7 @@ OSM
       create(:relation_member, :relation => relation, :member => node2)
 
       check_changeset_modify(BoundingBox.new(3, 3, 5, 5)) do |changeset_id|
-        relation_xml = relation.to_xml
+        relation_xml = xml_for_relation(relation)
         relation_xml
           .find("//osm/relation/member")
           .each(&:remove!)

test/controllers/api/ways_controller_test.rb

@@ -290,17 +290,17 @@ module Api
       assert_response :forbidden
 
       # try to delete with an invalid (closed) changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(private_way.to_xml, private_closed_changeset.id)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(private_way), private_closed_changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => private_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden
 
       # try to delete with an invalid (non-existent) changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(private_way.to_xml, 0)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(private_way), 0)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => private_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden
 
       # Now try with a valid changeset
-      xml = private_way.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(private_way)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => private_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden
 
@@ -311,12 +311,12 @@ module Api
       #   "delete request should return a new version number for way"
 
       # this won't work since the way is already deleted
-      xml = private_deleted_way.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(private_deleted_way)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => private_deleted_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden
 
       # this shouldn't work as the way is used in a relation
-      xml = private_used_way.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(private_used_way)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => private_used_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :forbidden,
                       "shouldn't be able to delete a way used in a relation (#{@response.body}), when done by a private user"
@@ -339,17 +339,17 @@ module Api
       assert_response :bad_request
 
       # try to delete with an invalid (closed) changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(way.to_xml, closed_changeset.id)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(way), closed_changeset.id)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict
 
       # try to delete with an invalid (non-existent) changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(way.to_xml, 0)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(way), 0)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict
 
       # Now try with a valid changeset
-      xml = way.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(way)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :success
 
@@ -360,12 +360,12 @@ module Api
              "delete request should return a new version number for way"
 
       # this won't work since the way is already deleted
-      xml = deleted_way.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(deleted_way)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => deleted_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :gone
 
       # this shouldn't work as the way is used in a relation
-      xml = used_way.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(used_way)
       delete :delete, :params => { :id => used_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :precondition_failed,
                       "shouldn't be able to delete a way used in a relation (#{@response.body})"
@@ -390,7 +390,7 @@ module Api
 
       ## First test with no user credentials
       # try and update a way without authorisation
-      xml = way.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(way)
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :unauthorized
 
@@ -402,33 +402,33 @@ module Api
       ## trying to break changesets
 
       # try and update in someone else's changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(private_way.to_xml,
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(private_way),
                              create(:changeset).id)
       put :update, :params => { :id => private_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_require_public_data "update with other user's changeset should be forbidden when date isn't public"
 
       # try and update in a closed changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(private_way.to_xml,
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(private_way),
                              create(:changeset, :closed, :user => private_user).id)
       put :update, :params => { :id => private_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_require_public_data "update with closed changeset should be forbidden, when data isn't public"
 
       # try and update in a non-existant changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(private_way.to_xml, 0)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(private_way), 0)
       put :update, :params => { :id => private_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_require_public_data("update with changeset=0 should be forbidden, when data isn't public")
 
       ## try and submit invalid updates
-      xml = xml_replace_node(private_way.to_xml, node.id, 9999)
+      xml = xml_replace_node(xml_for_way(private_way), node.id, 9999)
       put :update, :params => { :id => private_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_require_public_data "way with non-existent node should be forbidden, when data isn't public"
 
-      xml = xml_replace_node(private_way.to_xml, node.id, create(:node, :deleted).id)
+      xml = xml_replace_node(xml_for_way(private_way), node.id, create(:node, :deleted).id)
       put :update, :params => { :id => private_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_require_public_data "way with deleted node should be forbidden, when data isn't public"
 
       ## finally, produce a good request which will still not work
-      xml = private_way.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(private_way)
       put :update, :params => { :id => private_way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_require_public_data "should have failed with a forbidden when data isn't public"
 
@@ -440,28 +440,28 @@ module Api
       ## trying to break changesets
 
       # try and update in someone else's changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(way.to_xml,
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(way),
                              create(:changeset).id)
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict, "update with other user's changeset should be rejected"
 
       # try and update in a closed changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(way.to_xml,
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(way),
                              create(:changeset, :closed, :user => user).id)
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict, "update with closed changeset should be rejected"
 
       # try and update in a non-existant changeset
-      xml = update_changeset(way.to_xml, 0)
+      xml = update_changeset(xml_for_way(way), 0)
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict, "update with changeset=0 should be rejected"
 
       ## try and submit invalid updates
-      xml = xml_replace_node(way.to_xml, node.id, 9999)
+      xml = xml_replace_node(xml_for_way(way), node.id, 9999)
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :precondition_failed, "way with non-existent node should be rejected"
 
-      xml = xml_replace_node(way.to_xml, node.id, create(:node, :deleted).id)
+      xml = xml_replace_node(xml_for_way(way), node.id, create(:node, :deleted).id)
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :precondition_failed, "way with deleted node should be rejected"
 
@@ -469,26 +469,26 @@ module Api
       current_way_version = way.version
 
       # try and submit a version behind
-      xml = xml_attr_rewrite(way.to_xml,
+      xml = xml_attr_rewrite(xml_for_way(way),
                              "version", current_way_version - 1)
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict, "should have failed on old version number"
 
       # try and submit a version ahead
-      xml = xml_attr_rewrite(way.to_xml,
+      xml = xml_attr_rewrite(xml_for_way(way),
                              "version", current_way_version + 1)
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict, "should have failed on skipped version number"
 
       # try and submit total crap in the version field
-      xml = xml_attr_rewrite(way.to_xml,
+      xml = xml_attr_rewrite(xml_for_way(way),
                              "version", "p1r4t3s!")
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :conflict,
                       "should not be able to put 'p1r4at3s!' in the version field"
 
       ## try an update with the wrong ID
-      xml = create(:way).to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(create(:way))
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :bad_request,
                       "should not be able to update a way with a different ID from the XML"
@@ -500,7 +500,7 @@ module Api
                       "should not be able to update a way with non-OSM XML doc."
 
       ## finally, produce a good request which should work
-      xml = way.to_xml
+      xml = xml_for_way(way)
       put :update, :params => { :id => way.id }, :body => xml.to_s
       assert_response :success, "a valid update request failed"
     end
@@ -527,7 +527,7 @@ module Api
       tag_xml["v"] = "yes"
 
       # add the tag into the existing xml
-      way_xml = private_way.to_xml
+      way_xml = xml_for_way(private_way)
       way_xml.find("//osm/way").first << tag_xml
 
       # try and upload it
@@ -545,7 +545,7 @@ module Api
       tag_xml["v"] = "yes"
 
       # add the tag into the existing xml
-      way_xml = way.to_xml
+      way_xml = xml_for_way(way)
       way_xml.find("//osm/way").first << tag_xml
 
       # try and upload it
@@ -575,7 +575,7 @@ module Api
       tag_xml["v"] = private_existing_tag.v
 
       # add the tag into the existing xml
-      way_xml = private_way.to_xml
+      way_xml = xml_for_way(private_way)
       way_xml.find("//osm/way").first << tag_xml
 
       # try and upload it
@@ -593,7 +593,7 @@ module Api
       tag_xml["v"] = existing_tag.v
 
       # add the tag into the existing xml
-      way_xml = way.to_xml
+      way_xml = xml_for_way(way)
       way_xml.find("//osm/way").first << tag_xml
 
       # try and upload it
@@ -621,7 +621,7 @@ module Api
       tag_xml["v"] = "foobar"
 
       # add the tag into the existing xml
-      way_xml = private_way.to_xml
+      way_xml = xml_for_way(private_way)
 
       # add two copies of the tag
       way_xml.find("//osm/way").first << tag_xml.copy(true) << tag_xml
@@ -641,7 +641,7 @@ module Api
       tag_xml["v"] = "foobar"
 
       # add the tag into the existing xml
-      way_xml = way.to_xml
+      way_xml = xml_for_way(way)
 
       # add two copies of the tag
       way_xml.find("//osm/way").first << tag_xml.copy(true) << tag_xml

test/test_helper.rb

@@ -193,6 +193,62 @@ module ActiveSupport
       el
     end
 
+    def xml_for_way(way)
+      doc = OSM::API.new.get_xml_doc
+      doc.root << xml_node_for_way(way)
+      doc
+    end
+
+    def xml_node_for_way(way)
+      el = XML::Node.new "way"
+      el["id"] = way.id.to_s
+
+      OMHelper.add_metadata_to_xml_node(el, way, {}, {})
+
+      # make sure nodes are output in sequence_id order
+      ordered_nodes = []
+      way.way_nodes.each do |nd|
+        ordered_nodes[nd.sequence_id] = nd.node_id.to_s if nd.node&.visible?
+      end
+
+      ordered_nodes.each do |nd_id|
+        next unless nd_id && nd_id != "0"
+
+        node_el = XML::Node.new "nd"
+        node_el["ref"] = nd_id
+        el << node_el
+      end
+
+      OMHelper.add_tags_to_xml_node(el, way.way_tags)
+
+      el
+    end
+
+    def xml_for_relation(relation)
+      doc = OSM::API.new.get_xml_doc
+      doc.root << xml_node_for_relation(relation)
+      doc
+    end
+
+    def xml_node_for_relation(relation)
+      el = XML::Node.new "relation"
+      el["id"] = relation.id.to_s
+
+      OMHelper.add_metadata_to_xml_node(el, relation, {}, {})
+
+      relation.relation_members.each do |member|
+        member_el = XML::Node.new "member"
+        member_el["type"] = member.member_type.downcase
+        member_el["ref"] = member.member_id.to_s
+        member_el["role"] = member.member_role
+        el << member_el
+      end
+
+      OMHelper.add_tags_to_xml_node(el, relation.relation_tags)
+
+      el
+    end
+
     class OMHelper
       extend ObjectMetadata
     end